Alternativesto a heart rhythm study

There may be alternatives to heart rhythm studies.

For some people, the cause of a heart rhythm problem may be diagnosed with a less invasive and less expensive procedure. There are also other ways of treating certain types of arrhythmia, without a diagnostic test.

Diagnostic procedures

There are a number of less invasive diagnostic procedures that may be able to identify the cause of your arrhythmia. However, these procedures can only diagnose the problem. You may still need more invasive treatment. If you decide to go ahead with a heart rhythm study, your doctor may be able to diagnose and treat the problem in one go.

Less invasive alternatives to heart rhythm studies include:


If your arrhythmia is happening frequently, your doctor may be able to diagnose it with an electrocardiogram (ECG). During an ECG, you lie on a table and a technician attaches electrodes to your chest with adhesive. Your skin may be shaved to make them stick. Wires connect the electrodes to the monitor device.

Holter monitor

If your arrhythmia is intermittent, an ordinary ECG may not be able to capture it. A holter monitor is a portable ECG machine that records the activity of your heart over a period of 24 hours (or longer). At the cardiac clinic a technician attaches electrodes to your chest with adhesive. Wires connect the electrodes to the monitor device. You can wear the monitor like a shoulder bag or a pouch attached to your waist.

You can go about your normal activities except that you can’t bathe while you’re wearing it and some people find the electrodes irritating. The technician may give you a diary to record any symptoms you experience during the monitoring period. Next day you go back to the clinic and the technician removes the wires. You doctor can then analyse the data that’s been recorded and may be able to pinpoint the cause of your arrhythmia.

Tilt table testing

Your doctor may recommend tilt table testing if you have unexplained fainting spells (syncope), which may be caused by an arrhythmia. During tilt table testing, you’ll lie on a table with electrodes attached to your chest and a blood pressure monitor. The table is moved from a horizontal to a vertical position. The change in position may bring on the arrhythmia.


An echocardiogram uses ultrasound to create a picture of your heart as it moves. It enables your doctor to see the size and shape of your heart and how it’s working. It may be used at the same time as other tests such as stress testing which shows how your heart works when you exercise. A transoesophageal echocardiogram (or TOE) is a special type of echocardiogram where the doctor guides a probe down your throat and into your oesophagus (swallowing tube). It can provide more detailed pictures than a standard echocardiogram.

Implantable loop recorder

This procedure requires minor surgery to implant a small device under the skin of your chest. Your doctor may recommend this if you’re having palpitations or fainting spells that only happen occasionally. A loop recorder is about the size of a USB stick, or less. It can be left in place for up to 2 years.


If your doctors don’t think you’re a good candidate for a heart rhythm study, then they may suggest starting you on medication to try and control the arrhythmia.

Alternative techniques

Yoga and increased physical activity may improve certain types of arrhythmias. Before trying these approaches, it’s important to discuss your plans with your doctor, as some kinds of arrhythmias can be life-threatening if not treated correctly.

Results vs risks of the procedure

The benefits and potential complications of heart rhythm studies.


Information is provided by HCF in good faith for the convenience of members. It is not an endorsement or recommendation of any form of treatment nor is it a substitute for medical advice, and you should rely on the advice of your treating doctors in relation to all matters concerning your health. Every effort has been taken to ensure the accuracy of the information, however HCF takes no responsibility for any injury, loss, damage or other consequences of the use of this information.