Walking vs running: Which is better for your health?
Cardio exercise is one of the best things you can do for your health - walking and running are both great options. Here’s a roundup of the main benefits of adding them into your exercise routine.
Exercising outdoors in small groups, and without equipment, is one of the safest and most enjoyable ways to stay active.
Walking and running are two obvious choices that meet the brief – and offer a range of health benefits. So, which one should you choose?
Why cardio exercise is good for you
Regardless of your age, weight or sporting prowess, cardio exercise – any continuous exercise that gets your heart rate up and burns a number of calories – is great for your health and any weight loss goals you might have.
"There is scarcely anything else you can do in your day that will give you such an abundance of benefits," says Adjunct Professor Trevor Shilton, director of active living at the Heart Foundation.
Walking vs running
If you’re wondering whether walking or running is the better choice, it’s important to understand it’s not an either-or situation.
"Walking and running are both great choices for improving fitness and health," says Adjunct Prof Shilton.
"Walking regularly for 30-60 minutes a day can achieve all the same health benefits as running. The only disadvantage is that it will take you longer, due to its slower pace."
Indeed, Australia’s Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviour Guidelines recommend 150-300 minutes of moderate physical activity like brisk walking, or 75-150 minutes of vigorous physical activity like running, each week.
Benefits of walking
Walking is something everyone can do. It’s easy, cost-free and flexible. You can do it at any time of the day – as a dedicated exercise session, or as a mode of transport to the shops or a friend’s house.
"If you're looking for an inclusive form of exercise like starting a walking group, it's something that most people will be able to participate in," says accredited exercise physiologist Tim Douge, a spokesperson for Exercise & Sports Science Australia.
Adjunct Prof Shilton says walking carries fewer injury risks and is especially suitable for older adults and people who are overweight or affected by chronic conditions like heart disease and diabetes.
"Because walking is low-impact, the joints and bones are only put under minimal stress, and therefore the risk of injury is lower," he explains.
Walking is a great choice if you’re new to exercise or returning after a break.
"For people coming from a sedentary base, there are improvements in quality of life and functional capacity, such as improvements in strength, balance, heart and lung performance, and memory and cognition," says Tim.
Benefits of running
If you want to really improve your fitness, running is a great choice.
"The intensity can be varied from anything from a jog through to a sprint," says Tim. "With running, you’re putting consistent stress on the cardiovascular system, and you're going through a significant range of motion in terms of accelerating and decelerating the body."
It’s also ideal for working towards a goal, like a 30-minute run without stopping or aiming to beat a personal-best time.
"Many runners enjoy the feeling of achievement that it engenders," says Adjunct Prof Shilton. "What many call an ‘endorphin rush’ can really get you hooked."
And despite many people thinking it is high impact, running can be good for your knees and joints. "People often think putting more pressure on the joints leads to increased wear and tear, but most of the research suggests that it's the opposite effect," says Tim.
"Research shows that people who have a degenerative condition like osteoarthritis in the knee joints, if they are runners or have been runners, the progression of their disease is slower."
If you’re new to running, Adjunct Prof Shilton says it can be helpful to start with alternating intervals of running and walking. "In a 30-minute session, you might choose to alternate running for five minutes and walking for five minutes," he says.
That said, the risk of osteoarthritis increases among runners who’ve had a knee injury or knee surgery in the past, have a higher body mass index (BMI) or are in an older age group – so it’s best to tread carefully.
As always, speak with your GP before beginning any new exercise and start slowly. If any exercise doesn’t feel right for your body or fitness level, stop and consult a medical professional. And consider finding the right sports shoe for your activity.
Looking to lose weight?
HCF’s free Healthy Weight for Life programs help improve your quality of life if you’re overweight and have Type 2 diabetes, a chronic heart condition or osteoarthritis.
You must have had an eligible hospital product for 12 months. We also support eligible members who are overweight and at risk of developing chronic conditions.
Words by Angela Tufvesson
First Published June 2020
7 non-fitness reasons why you should exercise
Exercise doesn’t just keep you trim, it enhances your wellbeing from head to toe. Here’s how.
ADDRESSING DIABETES: A DUAL APPROACH
At HCF, we’re investing in research and providing access to tailored health management programs.
KNEE REPLACEMENT: WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
A knee replacement can be a daunting prospect, but it could give you a new lease on life.
FINDING THE RIGHT SPORTS SHOE FOR YOU
Want to get active but overwhelmed by all the types of sports shoe? Here’s some expert advice on finding the right fit.